Rather than a traditional, origins-to-legacy biography, Reeder opts for a thematic approach, taking the reader through each of Emma’s major roles in her life and in the early Church: her marriage to Joseph Smith, her mothering both of her own children and serving as a mother figure to many other children in the community, her business experience and political activism, her roles as the first “presidentess” of the Church’s women’s organization (the Relief Society), the first scribe to Joseph Smith’s scriptural translations, and the assembler of the Church’s first hymnal (and at least two more hymnals after that).
Reeder is careful to separate her speculation (based on her expertise and the historical record) from what is actually documented. The word “may” appears time and again: Emma may have been thinking this or she may have been feeling that. While we as readers might wish to know the inner goings on of Emma with greater certainty, Reeder’s honesty in this regard is refreshing. While she mentions some of the stories told about Emma in Utah after other members of the Church migrated there while Emma remained in Nauvoo, Reeder is careful to separate reminiscences (which “often reflect the time they were written, rather than the actual moment”) from concurrent accounts of events.
While I believe anyone interested in this essential actor in the early years of a modern religious movement could enjoy and would learn a great deal from this book, the primary audience is clearly believing members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Reeder makes references to the atonement of Jesus Christ, and she takes the prophetic role of Joseph Smith at face value. She engages Joseph’s practice of polygamy and Emma’s discomfort with the practice but treads carefully in this area. Yet she also treats Emma’s role in another church after Joseph’s death (the Re-organized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) with great respect.
I knew something of Emma’s life before reading (okay, listening to) this book (mostly from Doctrine and Covenants 25 and from biographies of Joseph Smith), but I cannot overstate how much I learned from seeing Emma in the starring role in this biography. I hope to read it again so that the life of this “elect lady” (as she is referred to in Latter-day Saint scripture) can rest upon my mind and heart.